I may be a minority, but my two beefs with Shaw’s arc, are that I thought finding out Sarah was the one who killed his wife was the perfect motive, but it felt like we needed maybe ONE other set up to see him truly go over the edge and switch sides -at least from a viewer standpoint. But, I also understand that at the time, all Fidak and Schwartz knew they had was the 13-episode order. The other is that the final fight with Chuck in “Santa Suit” felt like a big dismissal of the fact that Shaw was already a trained killer before becoming the Ring intersect. Not to dismiss Chuck’s polished skill as a fighter, but I thought he bested him too easily.

Other than that, yeah, Shaw is the perfect “Chuck” nemesis!

Mel- I would/will volunteer to do a list. I trust my ability as far as choosing the “moments”. However, right now a couple of things I need help on- my computer skills are not the greatest so I need a hint on how to properly label the moments as far as identifying them so people could find them. Just do it by the minute & second for beginning and ending? Choose from all 91 episodes broken down to each year. I know how long it took me to just finish rewatching every episode so if there were five volunteers we could make headway fast enough to keep interest up. If not, and I do all of them, I would review each episode in a scanning fashion to speed it up.

Would it be C&S “moments” or C&S romantic moments. Got to get specific on that part. They had some great moments that were not especially romantic. I personally think the more specific (such as romantic) the easier it would be, and less room for disagreeing.

I am serious about this, but it depends on your feed back. Thanks.

Yeah, narrowing down the picks to vote on is the most time-consuming task. If someone wants to volunteer to put together a list of Chuck & Sarah moments, that would be a very cool tournament.

Do the same for best “one liners” and/or all the ideas mentioned so far. It seems narrowing picks down to a managable vote size would be the hardest. You could really burn some brain cells putting another tournament together, but it’s “CHUCK”.

Like others, I miss Chuck too!